star heart codex
Sapphire CityBS04

Public Stone

6 min read·1,129 words

Once you understand what Sovereign Stone is, you will see a potential problem if we let that concept run freely. It would basically be anarchy... Sovereign Stone needs to be balanced with Public Stone.

Sovereign vs Public

If we all have Sovereign Stone, clashes will be inevitable. What I consider my rightful Stone could directly clash with what you consider your rightful Stone. As humans, we discovered that anarchy is generally incredibly costly for Stone, so we invented Cities and agreed to limit some of our own Sovereignty in the service of Public Stone.

While the Sovereign Stone of an Earthborn – your body, possessions, and basic rights – is easy to grasp, Public Stone is much less material.

Wanna Trade Stones?

Like many other things, the Crimson City kind of muddied the beauty of Public Stone... In the past, Public Stone was simply what was owned by the tribe. You shared your harvest with those who would help you survive. These old transactions were simple, and relatively quid-pro-quo.

Nowadays, Public Stone is also about taxing the number of sugar cubes inside the drink you bought at the supermarket. Not necessarily against such a tax – but the transaction is less clearly beneficial for your personal survival. Or, in other words, the Stone you pay for the Public Stone has much less direct returns. This is inevitable as a society grows more complex, but it is also a very good opportunity for the Crimson City to extract wealth without giving much back.

The Codex thus clearly would acknowledge a need for taxes: the individual jumps from the Micro to the Macro Level, Earthborn become a City, and Sovereign Stone becomes Public. This is not an argument against taxation. It is an argument against opaque tax systems.

Sapphire Taxes

Yeah, that header might sound like Crimson creeped into the room. Yet, Sapphire City, the Codex’ ideal City centred on integrated Love, would still need taxes...

I am not an economic expert. Please, let them do the calculations and correct the silly ideas of this Timeseer. Yet, I think one concept in the Stone exchange we saw earlier might make for much better taxes. I call it Parallel Taxes – and yes, I might have reinvented a wheel here. Feel free to scold me. Still gonna write my idea :p.

The Price of A Sugar Cube

For me, a tax would feel fair when I can clearly follow what is done with the Stone I give away. Let’s return to the sugar cube tax. The simplified idea behind that tax is:

  • Sugar leads to obesity and disease
  • Obesity and disease cost money to the City
  • The City collects money for each sold sugar cube
  • The City spends money to ‘treat’ obesity and disease

But there is a problem with this. Because that was the explanation and the stated idea. However, if you follow the money, you see the following path:

  • The City collects money for each sold sugar cube
  • The City spends money to ‘treat’ obesity

Imagine that treating obesity costs 20 million euros per year. Now, imagine that the City collects 40 million euros with the sugar cube tax that year. The way most tax systems are organised, there is no direct 1:1 relationship between tax and effect. I want taxes to be Parallel.

The Price of A Sugar CubeThe City collects 40 million euros from the sugar cube tax: four traces, ten million euros each. Two traces pay for treating obesity, 20 million euros. The other two, 20 million euros, are too much this year. 40 million euroscollected for each sold sugar cube20 million eurostreating obesity20 million eurostoo much this yearone trace = €10 million
Parallel Taxes

In our example, the City could choose to not levy the tax next year – it taxed 20 million too much this year. This would mean the sugar cube tax is temporarily cancelled for the next year. Even better, the City could spend a bit of effort in making budget predictions each year, and adapt the sugar cube tax to the projected cost of ‘treating’ obesity. Maybe add a small margin for safety. But not 20 million.

Restoring the Ancient Pact

This idea would even work for more abstract taxes such as income tax. Even if the relationship is less 1:1, Parallel Taxes can still be formulated. For example, you can argue that your ability to work was partially made possible by public school funding. Also, you can be a bit generous to the jobless people, and pay them an unemployment benefit. You would get that unemployment benefit too if you ever lose your job. Even abstract taxes can make sense in a Parallel system.

However, some taxes might be harder to explain... The inheritance tax is a bit absurd in this context. Why should you pay the City for the generous possibility of dying and transmitting your Sovereign Stone? Let’s not even go into historical taxes, it can get even more absurd. The French window tax made for a very dark City...

I do realise that the idea of Parallel Taxes needs much more elaboration – a great task for economic experts. But the basis, the 1:1 relationship between tax-effect and the transparency in fund allocation, I think is essential for a tax system people would psychologically accept. It would restore trust in the archaic pact we signed up for when we made some of our Sovereign Stone available to the City.

It’s Not Just Money

I used money as an example for Public Stone because it is easy to grasp. Yet, Public Stone can be much more, and we should decide together what we want our Public Stone to actually encompass. Medical security is a choice – we could choose to exclude it from Public Stone and let poor people rot in the street. I would abhor living in such a City, but the point remains we should try to reach a common understanding of what we want Public Stone to mean.

One thing I would vehemently fight for is the inclusion of the natural environment into Public Stone. I don’t think spreading poisons around can ever be defended as a fundamental right belonging to Sovereign Stone. You’re killing other Earthborn. In how far nature should be protected, can be open to discussion. Although, considering the state of biodiversity, I would go pretty far to save all the fucking forests, oceans and rivers of the magnificent Earth we were born from.

This idea does not even stem from a spiritual “Codex loves nature” vibe. My argument is fundamentally economical. If you kill the Earth, you’re just slowly killing yourself and your children. Fuck you!

Codex Reipublicae Vindex

I think the Public Stone discussion above illustrates best what I mean when I say the Codex can inform government policies. Not as a direct prescriber of mystical-sounding rules. The Codex can take many seemingly disconnected topics – from abortion to tax systems – and recentre the discussion around one single Elemental: Stone • E2. I hope it helps dispel some of the noise that can cloud our modern political discussions, and ultimately benefit our democratic process.

Blood-Heart