When are multiple mappings equally valid?
When the context is clearly chosen, there should be only a single valid mapping. But in practice, choosing a crystal clear unambiguous context is harder than the mapping itself. Take something high resolution, like the country ‘Russia’.
Geographically, it is very large. This context would map Russia to E9 (Gold). But if I change the context to something more cultural (which is also more diffuse and subjective), we could map Russia to E10 (Dust). Russia has a fatalistic current running through its culture – the idea that life is hard and you have to carry it on your shoulders. The language itself is highly structured. Society has a tendency towards adherence to hierarchy. Overall, Russia has a ‘strict’, ‘classical’, ‘imperial’ feeling compared to other countries.
And that is the key here: ‘compared to other countries’. When mapping something complex, you are always comparing it to other things within that same context. If we switch our lens to look at ‘the culture of the United States of America’, we can easily defend the claim that Russia is more E10 than the US. Conversely, the US is much more E9 than Russia, culturally speaking of course. Americans value growth, giant houses, and oversized things.
When is a mapping simply wrong?
The example in the earlier question shows when a mapping would be wrong. Even in something as high-resolution as ‘human culture’, saying ‘US culture is more E10 than Russia’s’ is wrong to me. However, since None can hold One, we should discuss and explain our positions rather than just saying “I’m right”. It is not necessarily about making the most perfect Map. The true value of Crystal Vision is the process of testing the Map.
How do Facets constrain interpretation?
Facets complicate the matter because they expose the complexity of the context. For example, the US’s culture does have E10 Facets – any culture has. In fact, every culture has Facets of all the Elementals. What matters when mapping is trying to find out how strongly a specific Facet is expressed compared to other Facets.
How much freedom does Crystal Vision actually allow?
A lot. Because we experience a high-resolution reality, we can see Facets anywhere. One helpful exercise to train yourself is to force a mapping (and yes, I hear the scientists flinch now). But, what you do is basically say something wild like ‘US culture = highly E3’, and then try to defend that position. It does not ultimately matter whether the mapping is wrong or right. What matters is the thought process that increases your ability to handle uncertainty, to change frames, and to become flexible when dealing with abstraction.
Can two Timeseers disagree forever?
Yes, of course. Just like scientists, philosophers, artists... However, the Codex is clear on one point. As a Timeseer, you do not let that disagreement collapse Order. You try to find Peace, and when in disagreement, you still try to build an Order around it. Basically, it tells you not to stay stuck in fruitless conflict.
Can Crystal Vision become automatic?
Yes, and no. I have been inside the system for a long time. Speaking from experience, I still need to consciously think about my maps. But, the brain has a way of making pathways to facilitate thought. Once you start training the muscle, insights become quicker and quicker.
