Is the Codex dangerous?
Overall, the Codex is not more dangerous than any system of thought.
The Codex asks you to be comfortable with uncertainty within certain conceptual pillars. Most dangerous effects from systems of thought come from the promotion of certainty inside uncertain conceptual frameworks.
For example, traditional Christianity dictates that homosexuality is bad (certainty), because God said so (uncertain context). The Codex does not discuss homosexuality because it is irrelevant.
Instead, it does describe Evil as an Excess that does not want to see itself (uncertain definition of Evil), but it also places Evil within a natural geometry; in other words, even Evil has a place in the Codex (certain conceptual pillar). Thus, whether the Codex is dangerous depends on how well you understand the framework.
To sidestep the question, the primary pillars of the Codex are Truth, Love, Peace, and Order. Thus, no, the Codex does not promote anything inherently dangerous or negative.
What are the most common beginner mistakes?
Thinking you understand it all. Even I don’t. And using it inappropriately as a replacement for reality. Humans are biologically built to have spiritual experiences and the Codex will likely activate that channel inside of you. This is why I constantly try to bring my writing back to common everyday reality. Please do not do stupid things!
“Some practical claims overreach: rigid masturbation schedule, claims about the effectiveness of Magic practices, the use of substances to free River-Dweller...”
I don’t think you read well. Every one of those claims does contain hedges. None of the claims are rigid. And if you want a rigid scientific review, I invite you to pay 35 euros and go read a scientific review. Maybe you can come back after science answers: “the evidence is inconclusive”. For the sake of over-hedging: none of those practical claims should be taken as literal truths. Don’t stop thinking. Being critical is good. Being uncritical of your own criticism is what annoys me.
